kdl/SPEC_v1.md

# KDL v1 Spec

This is the semi-formal specification for the legacy version of KDL, including
the intended data model and the grammar.

This document describes KDL version `1.0.0`. It was released on September 11, 2021.

Information in this spec is intended as both an accessible historical record,
and a reference for KDL implementors who are interested in supporting both major
versions of the language.

The v1 spec will not receive further updates outside of minor, inconsequential
rewordings or other superficial fixes and is considered a "legacy" version.

## Compatibility

KDL v2 is designed such that for any given KDL document in either v1 or v2, the
parse will either fail completely, or, if the parse succeeds, the data
represented by a v1 or v2 parser will be identical. This means that it's safe to
use a fallback parsing strategy in order to support both v1 and v2
simultaneously. For example, `node "foo"` is a valid node in both versions, and
should be represented identically by parsers.

KDL v2 is designed such that for any given KDL document written as KDL
1.0 or [KDL 2.0](https://kdl-org.github.io/kdl/#go.draft-marchan-kdl2.html),
the parse will either fail completely, or, if the
parse succeeds, the data represented by a v1 or v2 parser will be identical.
This means that it's safe to use a fallback parsing strategy in order to support
both v1 and v2 simultaneously. For example, `node "foo"` is a valid node in both
versions, and should be represented identically by parsers.

A version marker `/- kdl-version 1` (or `2`) _MAY_ be added to the beginning of
a KDL document, optionally preceded by the BOM, and parsers _MAY_ use that as a
hint as to which version to parse the document as.

## Introduction

KDL is a node-oriented document language. Its niche and purpose overlaps with
XML, and as do many of its semantics. You can use KDL both as a configuration
language, and a data exchange or storage format, if you so choose.

The bulk of this document is dedicated to a long-form description of all
[Components](#components) of a KDL document. There is also a much more terse
[Grammar](#full-grammar) at the end of the document that covers most of the
rules, with some semantic exceptions involving the data model.

KDL is designed to be easy to read _and_ easy to implement.

In this document, references to "left" or "right" refer to directions in the
*data stream* towards the beginning or end, respectively; in other words,
the directions if the data stream were only ASCII text. They do not refer
to the writing direction of text, which can flow in either direction,
depending on the characters used.

## Components

### Document

The toplevel concept of KDL is a Document. A Document is composed of zero or
more [Nodes](#node), separated by newlines and whitespace, and eventually
terminated by an EOF.

All KDL documents should be UTF-8 encoded and conform to the specifications in
this document.

#### Example

The following is a document composed of two toplevel nodes:

```kdl
foo {
    bar
}
baz
```

### Node

Being a node-oriented language means that the real core component of any KDL
document is the "node". Every node must have a name, which is an
[Identifier](#identifier).

The name may be preceded by a [Type Annotation](#type-annotation) to further
clarify its type, particularly in relation to its parent node. (For example,
clarifying that a particular `date` child node is for the _publication_ date,
rather than the last-modified date, with `(published)date`.)

Following the name are zero or more [Arguments](#argument) or
[Properties](#property), separated by either [whitespace](#whitespace) or [a
slash-escaped line continuation](#line-continuation). Arguments and Properties
may be interspersed in any order, much like is common with positional
arguments vs options in command line tools.

[Children](#children-block) can be placed after the name and the optional
Arguments and Properties, possibly separated by either whitespace or a
slash-escaped line continuation.

Arguments are ordered relative to each other (but not relative to Properties)
and that order must be preserved in order to maintain the semantics.

By contrast, Property order _SHOULD NOT_ matter to implementations.
[Children](#children-block) should be used if an order-sensitive key/value
data structure must be represented in KDL.

Nodes _MAY_ be prefixed with `/-` to "comment out" the entire node, including
its properties, arguments, and children, and make it act as plain whitespace,
even if it spreads across multiple lines.

Finally, a node is terminated by either a [Newline](#newline), a semicolon (`;`)
or the end of the file/stream (an `EOF`).

#### Example

```kdl
foo 1 key="val" 3 {
    bar
    (role)baz 1 2
}
```

### Identifier

An Identifier is either a [Bare Identifier](#bare-identifier), which is an
unquoted string like `node` or `item`, or a [String](#string), which is quoted,
like `"node"` or `"two words"`. There's no semantic difference between the
kinds of identifier; this simply allows for the use of quotes to have unusual
identifiers that are inexpressible as bare identifiers.

### Bare Identifier

A Bare Identifier is composed of any Unicode codepoint other than [non-initial
characters](#non-initial-characters), followed by any number of Unicode
codepoints other than [non-identifier characters](#non-identifier-characters),
so long as this doesn't produce something confusable for a [Number](#number),
[Boolean](#boolean), or [Null](#null). For example, both a [Number](#number)
and an Identifier can start with `-`, but when an Identifier starts with `-`
the second character cannot be a digit. This is precisely specified in the
[Full Grammar](#full-grammar) below.

Identifiers are terminated by [Whitespace](#whitespace) or
[Newlines](#newline).

### Non-initial characters

The following characters cannot be the first character in a
[Bare Identifier](#identifier):

* Any decimal digit (0-9)
* Any [non-identifier characters](#non-identifier-characters)

Be aware that the `-` character can only be used as an initial
character if the second character is not a digit. This allows
identifiers to look like `--this`, and removes the ambiguity
of having an identifier look like a negative number.

### Non-identifier characters

The following characters cannot be used anywhere in a [Bare Identifier](#identifier):

* Any codepoint with hexadecimal value `0x20` or below.
* Any codepoint with hexadecimal value higher than `0x10FFFF`.
* Any of `\/(){}<>;[]=,"`

### Line Continuation

Line continuations allow [Nodes](#node) to be spread across multiple lines.

A line continuation is a `\` character followed by zero or more whitespace
characters and an optional single-line comment. It must be terminated by a
[Newline](#newline) (including the Newline that is part of single-line comments).

Following a line continuation, processing of a Node can continue as usual.

#### Example

```kdl
my-node 1 2 \  // comments are ok after \
        3 4    // This is the actual end of the Node.
```

### Property

A Property is a key/value pair attached to a [Node](#node). A Property is
composed of an [Identifier](#identifier), followed immediately by a `=`, and then a [Value](#value).

Properties should be interpreted left-to-right, with rightmost properties with
identical names overriding earlier properties. That is:

```kdl
node a=1 a=2
```

In this example, the node's `a` value must be `2`, not `1`.

No other guarantees about order should be expected by implementers.
Deserialized representations may iterate over properties in any order and
still be spec-compliant.

Properties _MAY_ be prefixed with `/-` to "comment out" the entire token and
make it act as plain whitespace, even if it spreads across multiple lines.

### Argument

An Argument is a bare [Value](#value) attached to a [Node](#node), with no
associated key. It shares the same space as [Properties](#properties), and may be interleaved with them.

A Node may have any number of Arguments, which should be evaluated left to
right. KDL implementations _MUST_ preserve the order of Arguments relative to
each other (not counting Properties).

Arguments _MAY_ be prefixed with `/-` to "comment out" the entire token and
make it act as plain whitespace, even if it spreads across multiple lines.

#### Example

```kdl
my-node 1 2 3 "a" "b" "c"
```

### Children Block

A children block is a block of [Nodes](#node), surrounded by `{` and `}`. They
are an optional part of nodes, and create a hierarchy of KDL nodes.

Regular node termination rules apply, which means multiple nodes can be
included in a single-line children block, as long as they're all terminated by
`;`.

#### Example

```kdl
parent {
    child1
    child2
}

parent { child1; child2; }
```

### Value

A value is either: a [String](#string), a [Number](#number), a
[Boolean](#boolean), or [Null](#null).

Values _MUST_ be either [Arguments](#argument) or values of
[Properties](#property).

Values (both as arguments and as properties) _MAY_ be prefixed by a single
[Type Annotation](#type-annotation).

### Type Annotation

A type annotation is a prefix to any [Node Name](#node) or [Value](#value) that
includes a _suggestion_ of what type the value is _intended_ to be treated as,
or as a _context-specific elaboration_ of the more generic type the node name
indicates.

Type annotations are written as a set of `(` and `)` with an
[Identifier](#identifier) in it. Any valid identifier is considered a valid
type annotation. There must be no whitespace between a type annotation and its
associated Node Name or Value.

KDL does not specify any restrictions on what implementations might do with
these annotations. They are free to ignore them, or use them to make decisions
about how to interpret a value.

Additionally, the following type annotations MAY be recognized by KDL parsers
and, if used, SHOULD interpret these types as follows:

#### Reserved Type Annotations for Numbers Without Decimals:

Signed integers of various sizes (the number is the bit size):

* `i8`
* `i16`
* `i32`
* `i64`

Unsigned integers of various sizes (the number is the bit size):

* `u8`
* `u16`
* `u32`
* `u64`

Platform-dependent integer types, both signed and unsigned:

* `isize`
* `usize`

#### Reserved Type Annotations for Numbers With Decimals:

IEEE 754 floating point numbers, both single (32) and double (64) precision:

* `f32`
* `f64`

IEEE 754-2008 decimal floating point numbers

* `decimal64`
* `decimal128`

#### Reserved Type Annotations for Strings:

* `date-time`: ISO8601 date/time format.
* `time`: "Time" section of ISO8601.
* `date`: "Date" section of ISO8601.
* `duration`: ISO8601 duration format.
* `decimal`: IEEE 754-2008 decimal string format.
* `currency`: ISO 4217 currency code.
* `country-2`: ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 country code.
* `country-3`: ISO 3166-1 alpha-3 country code.
* `country-subdivision`: ISO 3166-2 country subdivision code.
* `email`: RFC5322 email address.
* `idn-email`: RFC6531 internationalized email address.
* `hostname`: RFC1132 internet hostname (only ASCII segments)
* `idn-hostname`: RFC5890 internationalized internet hostname (only `xn--`-prefixed ASCII "punycode" segments, or non-ASCII segments)
* `ipv4`: RFC2673 dotted-quad IPv4 address.
* `ipv6`: RFC2373 IPv6 address.
* `url`: RFC3986 URI.
* `url-reference`: RFC3986 URI Reference.
* `irl`: RFC3987 Internationalized Resource Identifier.
* `irl-reference`: RFC3987 Internationalized Resource Identifier Reference.
* `url-template`: RFC6570 URI Template.
* `uuid`: RFC4122 UUID.
* `regex`: Regular expression. Specific patterns may be implementation-dependent.
* `base64`: A Base64-encoded string, denoting arbitrary binary data.

#### Examples

```kdl
node (u8)123
node prop=(regex)".*"
(published)date "1970-01-01"
(contributor)person name="Foo McBar"
```

### String

Strings in KDL represent textual [Values](#value), or unusual identifiers. A
String is either a [Quoted String](#quoted-string) or a
[Raw String](#raw-string). Quoted Strings may include escaped characters, while
Raw Strings always contain only the literal characters that are present.

### Quoted String

A Quoted String is delimited by `"` on either side of any number of literal
string characters except unescaped `"` and `\`. This includes literal
[Newline](#newline) characters, which means a String Value can encompass
multiple lines without behaving like a Newline for [Node](#node) parsing
purposes.

Strings _MUST_ be represented as UTF-8 values.

In addition to literal code points, a number of "escapes" are supported.
"Escapes" are the character `\` followed by another character, and are
interpreted as described in the following table:

| Name                          | Escape | Code Pt  |
|-------------------------------|--------|----------|
| Line Feed                     | `\n`   | `U+000A` |
| Carriage Return               | `\r`   | `U+000D` |
| Character Tabulation (Tab)    | `\t`   | `U+0009` |
| Reverse Solidus (Backslash)   | `\\`   | `U+005C` |
| Solidus (Forwardslash)        | `\/`   | `U+002F` |
| Quotation Mark (Double Quote) | `\"`   | `U+0022` |
| Backspace                     | `\b`   | `U+0008` |
| Form Feed                     | `\f`   | `U+000C` |
| Unicode Escape                | `\u{(1-6 hex chars)}` | Code point described by hex characters, up to `10FFFF` |

### Raw String

Raw Strings in KDL are much like [Quoted Strings](#quoted-string), except they
do not support `\`-escapes. They otherwise share the same properties as far as
literal [Newline](#newline) characters go, and the requirement of UTF-8
representation.

Raw String literals are represented as `r`, followed by zero or more `#`
characters, followed by `"`, followed by any number of UTF-8 literals. The
string is then closed by a `"` followed by a _matching_ number of `#`
characters. This allows them to contain raw `"` or `#` characters; only the
precise terminator (resembling `"##`, for example) ends the raw string. This
means that the string sequence `"` or `"#` and such must not match the closing
`"` with the same or more `#` characters as the opening `r`.

#### Example

```kdl
just-escapes r"\n will be literal"
quotes-and-escapes r#"hello\n\r\asd"world"#
```

### Number

Numbers in KDL represent numerical [Values](#value). There is no logical distinction in KDL
between real numbers, integers, and floating point numbers. It's up to
individual implementations to determine how to represent KDL numbers.

There are four syntaxes for Numbers: Decimal, Hexadecimal, Octal, and Binary.

* All numbers may optionally start with one of `-` or `+`, which determine whether they'll be positive or negative.
* Binary numbers start with `0b` and only allow `0` and `1` as digits, which may be separated by `_`. They represent numbers in radix 2.
* Octal numbers start with `0o` and only allow digits between `0` and `7`, which may be separated by `_`. They represent numbers in radix 8.
* Hexadecimal numbers start with `0x` and allow digits between `0` and `9`, as well as letters `A` through `F`, in either lower or upper case, which may be separated by `_`. They represent numbers in radix 16.
* Decimal numbers are a bit more special:
    * They have no radix prefix.
    * They use digits `0` through `9`, which may be separated by `_`.
    * They may optionally include a decimal separator `.`, followed by more digits, which may again be separated by `_`.
    * They may optionally be followed by `E` or `e`, an optional `-` or `+`, and more digits, to represent an exponent value.

### Boolean

A boolean [Value](#value) is either the symbol `true` or `false`. These
_SHOULD_ be represented by implementation as boolean logical values, or some
approximation thereof.

#### Example

```kdl
my-node true value=false
```

### Null

The symbol `null` represents a null [Value](#value). It's up to the
implementation to decide how to represent this, but it generally signals the
"absence" of a value. It is reasonable for an implementation to ignore null
values altogether when deserializing.

#### Example

```kdl
my-node null key=null
```

### Whitespace

The following characters should be treated as non-[Newline](#newline) [white
space](https://www.unicode.org/Public/UCD/latest/ucd/PropList.txt):

| Name                 | Code Pt |
|----------------------|---------|
| Character Tabulation | `U+0009`  |
| Space                | `U+0020`  |
| No-Break Space       | `U+00A0`  |
| Ogham Space Mark     | `U+1680`  |
| En Quad              | `U+2000`  |
| Em Quad              | `U+2001`  |
| En Space             | `U+2002`  |
| Em Space             | `U+2003`  |
| Three-Per-Em Space   | `U+2004`  |
| Four-Per-Em Space    | `U+2005`  |
| Six-Per-Em Space     | `U+2006`  |
| Figure Space         | `U+2007`  |
| Punctuation Space    | `U+2008`  |
| Thin Space           | `U+2009`  |
| Hair Space           | `U+200A`  |
| Narrow No-Break Space| `U+202F`  |
| Medium Mathematical Space | `U+205F`  |
| Ideographic Space    | `U+3000`  |

#### Multi-line comments

In addition to single-line comments using `//`, comments can also be started
with `/*` and ended with `*/`. These comments can span multiple lines. They
are allowed in all positions where [Whitespace](#whitespace) is allowed and
can be nested.

### Newline

The following characters [should be treated as new
lines](https://www.unicode.org/versions/Unicode16.0.0/core-spec/chapter-5/#G41643):

| Acronym | Name            | Code Pt |
|---------|-----------------|---------|
| CRLF    | Carriage Return and Line Feed | `U+000D` + `U+000A` |
| CR      | Carriage Return | `U+000D`  |
| LF      | Line Feed       | `U+000A`  |
| NEL     | Next Line       | `U+0085`  |
| FF      | Form Feed       | `U+000C`  |
| LS      | Line Separator  | `U+2028`  |
| PS      | Paragraph Separator | `U+2029` |

Note that for the purpose of new lines, CRLF is considered _a single newline_. `VT` `Vertical tab` `U+000B` was mistakenly excluded, but the v1 spec if frozen, so it's left unchanged.

## Full Grammar

```
nodes := linespace* (node nodes?)? linespace*

node := ('/-' node-space*)? type? identifier (node-space+ node-prop-or-arg)* (node-space* node-children ws*)? node-space* node-terminator
node-prop-or-arg := ('/-' node-space*)? (prop | value)
node-children := ('/-' node-space*)? '{' nodes '}'
node-space := ws* escline ws* | ws+
node-terminator := single-line-comment | newline | ';' | eof

identifier := string | bare-identifier
bare-identifier := ((identifier-char - digit - sign) identifier-char* | sign ((identifier-char - digit) identifier-char*)?) - keyword
identifier-char := unicode - linespace - [\/(){}<>;[]=,"]
keyword := boolean | 'null'
prop := identifier '=' value
value := type? (string | number | keyword)
type := '(' identifier ')'

string := raw-string | escaped-string
escaped-string := '"' character* '"'
character := '\' escape | [^\"]
escape := ["\\/bfnrt] | 'u{' hex-digit{1, 6} '}'
hex-digit := [0-9a-fA-F]

raw-string := 'r' raw-string-hash
raw-string-hash := '#' raw-string-hash '#' | raw-string-quotes
raw-string-quotes := '"' .* '"'

number := hex | octal | binary | decimal

decimal := sign? integer ('.' integer)? exponent?
exponent := ('e' | 'E') sign? integer
integer := digit (digit | '_')*
digit := [0-9]
sign := '+' | '-'

hex := sign? '0x' hex-digit (hex-digit | '_')*
octal := sign? '0o' [0-7] [0-7_]*
binary := sign? '0b' ('0' | '1') ('0' | '1' | '_')*

boolean := 'true' | 'false'

escline := '\\' ws* (single-line-comment | newline)

linespace := newline | ws | single-line-comment

newline := See Table (All line-break white_space)

ws := bom | unicode-space | multi-line-comment

bom := '\u{FEFF}'

unicode-space := See Table (All White_Space unicode characters which are not `newline`)

single-line-comment := '//' ^newline+ (newline | eof)
multi-line-comment := '/*' commented-block
commented-block := '*/' | (multi-line-comment | '*' | '/' | [^*/]+) commented-block
```