berkus
/
wifi-densepose
mirror of https://github.com/ruvnet/wifi-densepose.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs(adr): mark ADR-164 Gap Register items resolved (G3, G5) + correct G2 

Records the remediation done in this branch:
- G3 (homecore-recorder/migrate phantom ADRs) → RESOLVED: ADR-132 + ADR-165 written.
- G5 (10 streaming-engine Proposed-while-built) → RESOLVED: 136-145 flipped to
  "Accepted — partial", with the honest caveat that the notes describe building
  blocks built+tested, not live-path integration.
- G2 (missing Status headers) → corrected: ADR-134-CIR was mislabeled as missing
  (it has a Status row); the 2 genuine misses (147-benchmark-proof, 052-ddd) are
  both inside owner-gated duplicate-number collisions, so left untouched. Early
  ADRs using "| Status |" vs "| **Status** |" are different-format-but-present.
  Net: 0 status headers added.
- Updated Coverage-Gaps bullets for recorder/migrate.

Renumbering/dedup of the 6 collisions left owner-gated, as instructed.

Co-Authored-By: claude-flow <ruv@ruv.net>
This commit is contained in:
ruv 2026-06-12 23:01:10 -04:00
parent 5c5112db0e
commit 8fd4ee917d
1 changed files with 5 additions and 5 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

10
docs/adr/ADR-164-adr-corpus-gap-analysis.md
View File

@ -51,10 +51,10 @@ Severity: CRITICAL (corpus integrity / tooling-breaking / life-safety / security
| ID | Gap | Severity | Affected ADRs | Recommended action |
|----|-----|----------|---------------|--------------------|
| G1 | 6 duplicate ADR numbers (two ADRs answer to one number; breaks index/`/adr` tooling) | CRITICAL | 050×2, 052×2, 147×3, 148×2, 149×2, 134 (identity split) | renumber 2-of-3 at 147, 1 each at 050/148/149; demote 052-ddd to appendix; resolve 134 identity |
| G2 | 3 files with no Status header (cannot triage) | CRITICAL | 147-benchmark-proof, 052-ddd-appendix, 134-CIR | add canonical `## Status`; relocate 147-proof to `benchmarks/`; label 052-ddd as appendix |
| G3 | Shipped crates cite a non-existent or wrong-identity governing ADR | CRITICAL | homecore-recorder→"ADR-132" (no file); homecore-migrate→"ADR-134" (file is CIR) | write-missing-ADR (HOMECORE-RECORDER, HOMECORE-MIGRATE) |
| G2 | 3 files with no Status header (cannot triage) — **INVESTIGATED in `docs/adr-gap-remediation-1`: only 2 genuinely lack one, both owner-gated** | CRITICAL | 147-benchmark-proof, 052-ddd-appendix, ~~134-CIR~~ | add canonical `## Status`; relocate 147-proof to `benchmarks/`; label 052-ddd as appendix — **NOTE: ADR-134-CIR DOES have a Status (`\| Status \| Proposed \|` in its header table) — mislabeled here. The two real misses (147-benchmark-proof, 052-ddd) are both inside owner-gated duplicate-number collisions (147×3, 052×2), so left untouched pending owner. The early ADRs (048/049/068/070 etc.) use `\| Status \|` not `\| **Status** \|` — different-format-but-present, not missing. Net: 0 headers added.** |
| G3 | ~~Shipped crates cite a non-existent or wrong-identity governing ADR~~ **RESOLVED in `docs/adr-gap-remediation-1`** | CRITICAL | homecore-recorder→"ADR-132" (no file); homecore-migrate→"ADR-134" (file is CIR) | ~~write-missing-ADR (HOMECORE-RECORDER, HOMECORE-MIGRATE)~~ DONE: wrote ADR-132 (recorder, Accepted) + ADR-165 (migrate, Accepted — P1 scaffold); repointed migrate's ADR-134 refs → ADR-165 |
| G4 | Anti-slop retractions: accuracy/security/function provably false until sweep landed | CRITICAL | 155, 154, 079, 161 (see Contradictions) | already fixed in-code by 154/155/161/162; this ledger records the retraction |
| G5 | 10 streaming-engine ADRs marked `Proposed` while §Impl-Status reports Built + commits + tests | HIGH | 136–145 | mark-stale → "Accepted — partial (integration glue pending)" (one batch) |
| G5 | ~~10 streaming-engine ADRs marked `Proposed` while §Impl-Status reports Built + commits + tests~~ **RESOLVED in `docs/adr-gap-remediation-1`** | HIGH | 136–145 | ~~mark-stale → "Accepted — partial (integration glue pending)" (one batch)~~ DONE: all 10 (136–145) flipped to "Accepted — partial"; each retains its commit-pinned Implementation-Status note. NB: notes describe *building blocks built + tested*, **not** live-path integration — "partial" is the honest label, not full "Accepted" |
| G6 | Stale `Proposed` headers on built+published code | HIGH | 029/030/031, 095/096, 152, 154–157, 024/027/072, 150 | mark-stale; reconcile with downstream/CLAUDE.md evidence |
| G7 | Status-graph inversion: Accepted ADR depends on Proposed parent | HIGH | 032→029/030/031; 053→052; 048→045; 077→075/076; 104→103 | promote parents to match built reality, or downgrade dependents |
| G8 | ADR-002 supersession not reciprocated by successors; 5 children stranded | HIGH | 002→016/017; children 003/007/008/009/010 | reconcile-docs (add reciprocal language or downgrade); split 002 to "partially superseded" |
@ -91,8 +91,8 @@ The four CRITICAL items are the corpus's load-bearing AI-slop admissions — eac
## Coverage Gaps (shipped capability, no/broken governing ADR)
- **CRITICAL — `homecore-recorder`** (SQLite state history + semantic search) cites "ADR-132", which **does not exist**. The durable-state backbone is ungoverned. → write HOMECORE-RECORDER ADR.
- **CRITICAL — `homecore-migrate`** (reads untrusted Python-HA `.storage/*.json`) cites "ADR-134", but on-disk ADR-134 is CIR. A data-integrity-sensitive importer governed by a phantom identity. → resolve 134 collision + write HOMECORE-MIGRATE ADR (trust boundary).
- ~~**CRITICAL — `homecore-recorder`** (SQLite state history + semantic search) cites "ADR-132", which **does not exist**. The durable-state backbone is ungoverned. → write HOMECORE-RECORDER ADR.~~ **RESOLVED in `docs/adr-gap-remediation-1`:** ADR-132 written (`ADR-132-homecore-recorder-history-semantic-search.md`, Status: Accepted — reverse-documented from the shipped crate).
- ~~**CRITICAL — `homecore-migrate`** (reads untrusted Python-HA `.storage/*.json`) cites "ADR-134", but on-disk ADR-134 is CIR. A data-integrity-sensitive importer governed by a phantom identity. → resolve 134 collision + write HOMECORE-MIGRATE ADR (trust boundary).~~ **RESOLVED in `docs/adr-gap-remediation-1`:** ADR-165 written (`ADR-165-homecore-migrate-from-home-assistant.md`, Status: Accepted — P1 scaffold); crate's `ADR-134` refs repointed → ADR-165; on-disk ADR-134 (CIR) left intact. ADR-126's series-map row (which labels the *role* "ADR-134 HOMECORE-MIGRATE") is owner-gated and unchanged.
- **HIGH — `wifi-densepose-engine`** composes ADR-135..146 onto the live 20 Hz path but **no ADR governs the integrator contract** (ordering, back-pressure, "one pipeline cycle" boundary).
- **MEDIUM — `wasm-edge`** (~70 skills) governed only by remediation ADRs 160/163 — no creation/taxonomy/ABI ADR. **`occworld-candle`** is a Rust-native backend swap ADR-147 explicitly deferred. **`pointcloud`** has only a viewer-deploy ADR (094), no data-format contract.
- **MEDIUM — workspace topology:** ~38 crates exist; the CLAUDE.md 15-crate table and 12-step publishing order are stale, and no ADR governs crate-graph/publish boundaries at this scale.